BIG STORIES :
News Corp. | Phone Hacking Scandal | WikiLeaks | Barack Obama | Julian Assange | 2012 U.S. Election | Religion | See All
iMEDIAETHICS.org
Seperator
 
Tips Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter RSS Feeds
 
Home | | Contact Us

International Media Ethics News :
Daily Media Pick
Comments (0)
Print Tweet Email

BBC, TIME Hoaxed by Dog Stoning Story, Will AFP Correct?

By: Sydney Smith
June 26, 2011 08:15 AM EST
 
BBC, TIME Hoaxed by Dog Stoning Story, Will AFP Correct?
 
News outlets are retracting and correcting their reports that a dog was sentenced to stoning. (Credit: BBC, screenshot)
 

Add a fake dog stoning story to the (long) list of June's hoax stories that includes a Gay Girl in Damascus, the mass grave story, a French TV news station's fake interview with a Syrian ambassador, and a Toronto news station's report that the prime minister choked on a hash brown potato.

In the latest hoax, the BBC, Time magazine, the Telegraph and other news outlets published stories about a dog in Israel being condemned to stoning in Israel. As the BBC explained, the hoax story:

"It was reported that the dog reminded a judge of a curse passed on a now deceased secular lawyer about 20 years ago, when judges bid his spirit to enter the body of a dog. The animal was said to have escaped before the sentence was carried out."

Christian Science Monitor explained how the hoax story spread.  According to Christian Science Monitor, the story started when Behadrei Hadarim, described as "a small Hebrew-language news outlet for Israel's ultra-Orthodox community," reported an anonymously sourced account of the dog stoning incident.  That anonymous source "was present," according to CSM.

YNet picked up the story and included that the court denied the account and that "there was no official ruling."  Then, BBC, Agence France Presse, Time and others picked up the story, but none included that the story had been denied, Christian Science Monitor reported.

Christian Science Monitor likened this fake story to the reporting on the hoax mass grave story in Texas

Honest Reporting translated Ma'ariv's apology for its June 3 story, “Mea Shearim: Rabbinnical court orders the stoning of a dog.”

According to the apology, "The title of the story didn’t fully present the entire story, and we apologize for the anguish caused to the court and its members."

Before the story was revealed as a hoax, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals weighed in, labeling the stoning sentence "absurd" and against Jewish principles, Ma'an News Agency reported.

Corrections, Unpublishing

The BBC has unpublished its story.  According to the BBC's editors blog, the story was based on articles by Ynet and Agence France Presse, but the BBC didn't realize that the story had been retracted by Israeli-newspaper Maariv.

"We failed to make the right checks. We should never have written the article and apologise for any offence caused," the BBC explained.

The BBC noted it is keeping its story reporting the denials of the story up here

The AFP reported June 17 about the dog stoning, but StinkyJournalism hasn't seen any correction or update.  We are writing to the AFP for a correction and will update with any response.

The Jewish Chronicle reported that Yahoo News reported the story but has since removed it.

The Digital Journal reported on the story but posted an update letting readers know the story "was a media prank."

Line
Print   Print
Line
Twitter   Tweet
Report an Error Report an Error
Email   E-mail
Link Send a Tip
 
 
  RESOURCES FOR EDUCATORS
 
Checkout iMediaEthics Resources for Educators, a helpful section for colleges, institutions, students and teachers.
Ethics Codes Case Studies Sites We Like
Ethics Codes Case Studies Sites We Like
 
   DAVID MOORE ON POLLS [See All]   
9 in 10 Americans can be classified as Racist against Either Blacks or Whites?  What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes really tells Us, Part 2.
PollSkeptic Report:   9 in 10 Americans can be classified as Racist...
What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes Really Tells Us, Part 1
PollSkeptic Report:   What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes Really Tells...
David Moore
PollTalk Blog:   3 in 10 Voters Believe Armed Revolution Might Be...
   MORE BY THIS AUTHOR [See All]   
   RELATED STORIES
 
Al Jazeera Unpublishes 'Last of the Semites' Op-Ed, Admits It 'should have handled this better'
Al Jazeera Unpublishes 'Last of the Semites' Op-Ed, Admits It 'should have handled this better'
Al Jazeera unpublished an op-ed column by Joseph Massad...
 
Association of Food Journalists Revise Ethics Guidelines to 'Advance Ethical Standards'
Association of Food Journalists Revise Ethics Guidelines to 'Advance Ethical Standards'
The Association of Food Journalists released a revised...
 
NYT Public Editor Calls for One Standard in Using Photoshop, Disclosures
NYT Public Editor Calls for One Standard in Using Photoshop, Disclosures
A discussion on Photoshopping images in the news was...
 
Did US Justice Dept snooping put AP anonymous sources at risk?
Did US Justice Dept snooping put AP anonymous sources at risk?
How many anonymous sources were put at risk by the...
 
'Transgender Issues' after Apparent Suicide of Teacher Lucy Meadows, PCC to Advise Media
'Transgender Issues' after Apparent Suicide of Teacher Lucy Meadows, PCC to Advise Media
The UK Press Complaints Commission announced last week...
 
 Call To Penalize Media Outlets Violating Journalism Ethics in Ghana
Call To Penalize Media Outlets Violating Journalism Ethics in Ghana
Ghana Institute of Journalism rector David Newton called...
 
   SIMILAR TOPIC
 
Mike Bloomberg Only Allowed 1 Pizza Slice? Drudge Report Hoaxed by Daily Currant Satire Story
Mike Bloomberg Only Allowed 1 Pizza Slice? Drudge Report Hoaxed by Daily Currant Satire Story
 
Louisiana High School Newspaper's Prank Gone Wrong
Louisiana High School Newspaper's Prank Gone Wrong
A Louisiana high school's student newspaper...
 
9/11 Plane debris: NYPD doesn't believe it is a hoax
9/11 Plane debris: NYPD doesn't believe it is a hoax
 
Sarah Palin Wants to Invade Czech Republic? Polish Magazine Hoaxed by Satire Site's Fake Quotes
Sarah Palin Wants to Invade Czech Republic? Polish Magazine Hoaxed by Satire Site's Fake Quotes
Polish magazine Wprost was hoaxed by a satire article...
 
   TWITTER
   FACEBOOK
   LATEST STORIES [See All]