FOX News Broadcasts Bad Advice From H1N1 Flu "Expert"
BIG STORIES :
News Corp. | Phone Hacking Scandal | WikiLeaks | Barack Obama | Julian Assange | 2012 U.S. Election | Religion | See All
iMEDIAETHICS.org
Seperator
 
Tips Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter RSS Feeds
 
Home | | Contact Us

Sci/Tech/Health Journalism Ethics News :
Daily Media Pick
Comments (1)
Print Tweet Email

FOX News Broadcasts Bad Advice From H1N1 Flu "Expert"

By: Molika Ashford
October 08, 2009 04:44 AM EST
 
FOX News Broadcasts Bad Advice From H1N1 Flu "Expert"
 
Dr. Kent Holtorf, on right, is described by FOX News as an “infectious disease expert” they use to advise America as the fall flu season kicks off.
 

In a recent broadcast, “Tracking H1N1,” Fox News taps the wisdom of Dr. Kent Holtorf to advise America as the fall flu season kicks off.  They describe him as an “infectious disease expert.”

Twitter tipped me off again here, with @ivanoransky noting that Holtorf is, in fact, not an infectious disease expert, but an "anti-aging" specialist, according to the bio posted on the website of his own clinic, where he advocates the use of “bioidentical” hormone therapy for a (very broad) range of medical problems and symptoms. Holtorf’s clinic profits from selling their own individually mixed prescriptions, which they claim are better than hormone therapy available at regular pharmacies.

Holtorf’s arguments and published advice to patients about his brand of Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) are not supported by the FDA, or by well-controlled clinical trials. In the past, Holtorf has been accused of manipulating and cherry picking data to support the picture of HRT he advocates at his clinic. 

More germane to the recent broadcast on swine flu by Fox News, none of Dr. Holtorf’s activities or practices--whether they are clinically sound or not--appear to have much to do with infectious disease.

Yet, in the H1N1 Fox News report, the host twice identifies Holtorf as an expert on infectious disease, and allows him to make unchallenged statements about the safety of flu vaccines, confusing FOX’s audience who might make ill-informed medical decisions as a result.

“I have more concern about the vaccine than I do about the swine flu,” Holtorf says in the video, calling the H1N1 vaccine (of which the United States has approved several different versions) “Rushed to market” and saying that it has “high levels of adjuncts” and was created using an “unrefined method.” 

Holtorf then says that vaccines have been “highly implicated” in autism, and because the H1N1 flu vaccine contains the preservative thimerosal, he “definitely would not” have his children vaccinated for H1N1 flu.

Thimerosal-containing vaccines, and vaccines in general, have NOT been “highly implicated” in or linked scientifically to autism.  In a single case, a judicial ruling has linked vaccination to autism-like symptoms in a child with a mitochondrial disorder.  The court’s ruling, however, is not representative of a scientific proof of the link, according to this actual expert in infectious disease--Dr. Paul A. Offit, chief of infectious diseases at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia--writing in the New England Journal of Medicine. A more recent court ruling has since found no link in three other cases.

Moreover, Holtorf doesn’t seem to know that only some of the swine flu vaccines will contain thimerosal. The nasal spray version of the H1N1 vaccine, for example, will contain no thimerosal at all. Neither will single dose units of the injected vaccine, according to the CDC.  Only multi-dose vials of vaccine will require thimerosal as a preservative to prevent contamination inside a multi-dose vial, which can cause serious illness or death. 

Holtorf’s report is presented as that of an expert, but clearly he does not know his facts.  Thimerosal has not been scientifically shown to be dangerous, and vaccination is an important part of our national public health efforts.  To advocate against it is dangerous, and certainly suspect, for a doctor.  To bring on a guest who does so and tout them as an “expert” is dangerous practice for a news outfit, including Fox. 

Line
Print   Print
Line
Twitter   Tweet
Report an Error Report an Error
Email   E-mail
Link Send a Tip
 

You are right to question Dr. Kent Holtorf's qualifications as a specialist on infectious diseases. The California State Medical Board lists his primary and secondary areas of practice as family and endocrinology.


Comment by Bill H. | Oct 20, 2009 at 02:10 AM EST
 
 
  RESOURCES FOR EDUCATORS
 
Checkout iMediaEthics Resources for Educators, a helpful section for colleges, institutions, students and teachers.
Ethics Codes Case Studies Sites We Like
Ethics Codes Case Studies Sites We Like
 
   DAVID MOORE ON POLLS [See All]   
9 in 10 Americans can be classified as Racist against Either Blacks or Whites?  What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes really tells Us, Part 2.
PollSkeptic Report:   9 in 10 Americans can be classified as Racist...
What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes Really Tells Us, Part 1
PollSkeptic Report:   What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes Really Tells...
David Moore
PollTalk Blog:   Why the Midterm Election Polls Stunk
   MORE BY THIS AUTHOR [See All]   
   SIMILAR TOPIC
 
$4 Chinese food overcharge leads to fake racist email, T-shirt sales by reporter and Boston.com retraction
$4 Chinese food overcharge leads to fake racist email, T-shirt sales by reporter and Boston.com retraction
Boston.com reporter Hilary Sargent was suspended and...
 
John Wayne Escaped from Prison? Kentucky TV News Uses Famed Actor Photo for Inmate
John Wayne Escaped from Prison? Kentucky TV News Uses Famed Actor Photo for Inmate
A Kentucky television news station aired a photograph of...
 
NYTimes Mixes up Good Burger's Kel with Teenager
NYTimes Mixes up Good Burger's Kel with Teenager
The New York Times thought a still image from the movie...
 
Wash D.C. CBS-affiliate accuses candidate of embezzlement, confused ID with his son
Wash D.C. CBS-affiliate accuses candidate of embezzlement, confused ID with his son
Washington, D.C. CBS-affiliate wrongly accused a man...
 
   TWITTER
   FACEBOOK
   LATEST STORIES [See All]