BIG STORIES :
News Corp. | Phone Hacking Scandal | WikiLeaks | Barack Obama | Julian Assange | 2012 U.S. Election | Religion | See All
iMEDIAETHICS.org
Seperator
 
Tips Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter RSS Feeds
 
Home | | Contact Us

Sci/Tech/Health Journalism Ethics News :
Daily Media Pick
Comments (0)
Print Tweet Email

TIME Posts Twitter Photo with its 2010 NYC Storm Blog; Photo's Really from 1976

By: Sydney Smith
September 20, 2010 07:34 AM EST
 
TIME Posts Twitter Photo with its 2010 NYC Storm Blog; Photo's Really from 1976
 
See above a detail of a screenshot from Time's blog about the tornado photo. As the Huffington Post's Craig Kanalley noted, the photo isn't from Sept 2010 as Time first reported, but from July 1976. (Credit: Time)
 

Time magazine's Steven James Snyder featured a photo he found on Twitter with his blog about the Sept 16, 2010 storm and tornado warning that hit New York City.  But, the photo isn't from the storm on Sept. 16, 2010.  It's from a July 7, 1976 storm, a Huffington Post writer explains.

Huffington Post's traffics and trends editor, Craig Kanalley, detailed his findings in a HuffPost blog.  

Kanalley noted that Snyder's blog post was also tweeted and posted on StumbleUpon. "Needless to say, it got retweeted a bazillion times and did indeed go viral on Twitter, Facebook, and everywhere else," Kanalley wrote.

The photo - with the correct datestamp - can be found on the National Weather Service Forecast Office's website and in the book The Tornado Season of 1976.

Snyder's Time blog hasn't been removed, but a correction is now appended:

"Corrected 7:40 p.m: Since this story first posted, it has come to our attention that the image shown above is from 1976...but the video is indeed from Thursday. Original story follows"

According to Kanalley, Time has deleted the original tweet announcing Snyder's blog post and as of yet, has not posted a Twitter correction. 

Time credited its photo from Twitter user "The Dave Carlson."  Carlson had tweeted "Here's a photo of the Tornado in NYC: http://plixi.com/p/45484163"

In response to an inquiry from StinkyJournalism, Carlson wrote that he didn't know that the photo was dated.

"I pulled it from Google images to pull a prank on my friends. I had no idea it would become this big deal but once it started to happen I did find it funny," Carlson wrote.

He added that "TIME didn't contact me before posting the photo and I had only found out about it through a friend. After a few hours the writer sent an @reply to me stating the photo was from 1976. I knew that already through friends. I haven't heard from them since."

"It's important to keep in mind that this could have happened to any news organization and to any journalist. But we do need to be a lot more careful vetting information and making sure we get it right  before passing on to the world." Kanalley wrote.

The National Weather Service has found there were in fact two tornadoes Sept. 16 in New York.

Past Twitter Hoaxes

Time isn't alone in publishing faulty information.  In the past few months, StinkyJournalism has written about several media mistakes involving the short messaging service.

Most recently, StinkyJournalism reported Sept 12 when Washington Post's Jonathan Capehart was duped by a satirical Twitter account.  Capehart criticized the tweets of RepJackKimble, a fictional, self-identified 54th U.S. Congressman from California (the state currently has 53 U.S. Congressmen).

StinkyJournalism also reported in early September when Washington Post sports writer Mike Wise was suspended for 30 days for knowingly tweeting fake information.   Wise said at the time he tweeted the misinformation to prove a point about how media outlets will report information from the social media site without fact checking.

We also wrote June 30 about the UK newspaper the Daily Mail's publishing a story based on a tweet from a Steve Jobs parody Twitter account.  While that Twitter account discloses that it is a parody account, the Daily Mail still reported information from one of its tweets as if it were from the real spokesperson and founder of Apple.

 

Line
Print   Print
Line
Twitter   Tweet
Report an Error Report an Error
Email   E-mail
Link Send a Tip
 
 
  RESOURCES FOR EDUCATORS
 
Checkout iMediaEthics Resources for Educators, a helpful section for colleges, institutions, students and teachers.
Ethics Codes Case Studies Sites We Like
Ethics Codes Case Studies Sites We Like
 
   DAVID MOORE ON POLLS [See All]   
9 in 10 Americans can be classified as Racist against Either Blacks or Whites?  What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes really tells Us, Part 2.
PollSkeptic Report:   9 in 10 Americans can be classified as Racist...
What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes Really Tells Us, Part 1
PollSkeptic Report:   What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes Really Tells...
David Moore
PollTalk Blog:   Why 3 Polls on NSA Snooping Produce Wildly...
   MORE BY THIS AUTHOR [See All]   
   RELATED STORIES
 
Fox News Aired Man's Suicide, Children Sue for Emotional Distress
Fox News Aired Man's Suicide, Children Sue for Emotional Distress
Last year, Fox News aired live footage of a man named...
 
Retired NFL Player's Lou Gehrig's Disease Mocked, 3 Atlanta Radio Hosts Fired
Retired NFL Player's Lou Gehrig's Disease Mocked, 3 Atlanta Radio Hosts Fired
Atlanta's 790 The Zone radio station hosts Steak...
 
'Too many gosh darn foreigners' ('Asians') on LPGA Tour, Radio Host Fired after comment
'Too many gosh darn foreigners' ('Asians') on LPGA Tour, Radio Host Fired after comment
Rochester, New York news radio WHAM-AM fired radio host...
 
Nelson Mandela NOT Dead, Germany's Deutsche-Welle Wrong
Nelson Mandela NOT Dead, Germany's Deutsche-Welle Wrong
Deutsche Welle wrongly reported that Nelson Mandela...
 
BBC Reporter Promoted PR Wife's Business When Interviewing Students of Her Client
BBC Reporter Promoted PR Wife's Business When Interviewing Students of Her Client
Freelance BBC reporter Adam Kirtley, in effect, promoted...
 
White Sox Manager Didn't Say That! Fort Worth Star-Telegram Prints Fake Quote on Graduations
White Sox Manager Didn't Say That! Fort Worth Star-Telegram Prints Fake Quote on Graduations
The Fort Worth Star-Telegram was hoaxed by a satirical...
 
   SIMILAR TOPIC
 
Nelson Mandela NOT Dead, Germany's Deutsche-Welle Wrong
Nelson Mandela NOT Dead, Germany's Deutsche-Welle Wrong
Deutsche Welle wrongly reported that Nelson Mandela...
 
Former Alabama Gov George Wallace NOT a Republican, MSNBC Corrects
Former Alabama Gov George Wallace NOT a Republican, MSNBC Corrects
An MSNBC graphic wrongly said George Wallace -- who was...
 
White Sox Manager Didn't Say That! Fort Worth Star-Telegram Prints Fake Quote on Graduations
White Sox Manager Didn't Say That! Fort Worth Star-Telegram Prints Fake Quote on Graduations
The Fort Worth Star-Telegram was hoaxed by a satirical...
 
CNN Covers Up Error in Cleveland Kidnappings Case: Amanda Berry NOT Ariel Castro's Daughter's Best Friend
CNN Covers Up Error in Cleveland Kidnappings Case: Amanda Berry NOT Ariel Castro's Daughter's Best Friend
CNN's Michael Martinez made an error in his May 12...
 
   TWITTER
   FACEBOOK
   LATEST STORIES [See All]