Menu

Home » Fake Quotes»

See the Penguin News' fake interview (highlighted). (Credit: Penguin News, via La Nacion/Scribd, Screenshot, Highlight Added)

Falkland Islands newspaper the Penguin News made up an interview with Argentine Foreign Minister Héctor Timerman, the Knight Center for Journalism in Americas reported.

The made-up interview was published in the Feb. 8 edition of the paper, which identifies itself as a weekly newspaper and “the Falkland Islands’ only newspaper…with a circulation of 1,500 per week.”  According to the Penguin News’ website, it used to be “funded by the Falkland Islands Government,” but it’s now “financially independent.”

The interview was run as ten questions and answers under the headline “Give us two minutes…”  An example of the fake Q & A questions included:  “4. If you had a motto, what would it be?  ‘If you are going to lie, make it a big one.'”

Above is the first half of the phony interview. (Credit: Penguin News via La Nacion/Scribd, screenshot)

 

The interview isn’t labeled as satire or parody, but at the bottom of the ten question column is a note in bold and italics that reads:

“(Sadly, but not surprisingly, Mr Timerman did not himself supply this column’s content, but following his example, we decided to make it up anyway.)”

You May Also Like...

Did Sun Crime Reporter 'Conspire' to Commit 'Misconduct in Public Office'?

As the Knight Center for Journalism in the Americas, which spotted the fake interview, pointed out, the Q & A “had an ironic, satirical tone.”

 

The rest of the “interview.” Timerman “responded” to Question #9 “What is your happiest childhood memory?” by saying “Of a time when I could look my late father in the eye without feeling ashamed.” (Credit: Penguin News via La Nacion/Scribd, screenshot, highlight added)

 

As Minuto Uno explained (through a Google translate), the interview was published “shortly after the official refused to hold a meeting” with people from the island.  The BBC reported that the meeting was supposed to be in London with Foreign Secretary William Hague but Timerman wouldn’t go because, as the BBC explained, “representatives of the islanders were present.”  Hague has claimed Argentina is “bullying” the Falkland Islands.

iMediaEthics has written to the Penguin News’ managing editor Lisa Watson asking:

  • Is this Q & A a regular weekly feature? Is it always (except for this case) a real interview?
  • Why did the Penguin News decide to make this interview up?
  • What sort of reaction has the Penguin News seen to its phony interview?
  • Did the Penguin News ask the real foreign minister to be interviewed before deciding to publish the made-up interview? What did he say?

We’ll update with any response.

Submit a tip / Report a problem

Fake Interview with Argentine Foreign Minister Published by Falkland Islands’ Only Newspaper

Share this article:

One Response

  1. Cupcake says:

    I read a commentary piece in the Japan Times (http://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2013/02/17/commentary/whoever-could-pass-a-test-to-list-values-at-the-heart-of-being-japanese/#.USsfoqJHKSo) that supposedly cites questions from various nations’ citizenship exams, etc. The questions are pulled out of thin air and it’s obviously satirical (I think) but I don’t think the paper ever mentions anything about the story being a satire anywhere in, above, or below the article. The Japan Times is a bigger outfit than the Penguin but they don’t seem to be too big to pull the same kind of antics that would be more at home in the Onion.

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *