New York Times: Politicians Boiling Mad at Media

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Bias»

The New York Times reported this week that politicians' dislike of the media has started to "boil over." Pictured above is "Pew's 2009 press accuracy rating survey" that found fewer citizens, in general, "see accuracy, fairness in press." (Credit: Pew)

Politicians have let their dislike of the media “boil over” this year, according to an Oct. 31 New York Times report.

The Times highlighted several high-profile incidents of the media and politicians butting heads, including the recent detaining of an Alaskan reporter and Sarah Palin’s labeling the media “the lame stream media.”

  1. Alaskan Senate candidate Joe Miller:  As StinkyJournalism has previously reported, a reporter was detained and handcuffed by private security guards at one of Miller’s “town hall” meetings last month.  In a statement, Miller labeled Alaska Dispatch editor Tony Hopfinger “irrational, angry and potentially violent.”
  2. New York representative Charlie Rangel: Rangel criticized MSNBC reporter Luke Russert for asking a “dumb question” in July.
  3. New York governor candidate Carl Paladino:  Paladino and New York Post reporter Fred Dicker got into a “shouting match,” the Times recounts.  The argument happened in late September and Paladino is reported to have said “I’ll take you out, buddy!”
  4. Nevada Senate candidate Sharron Angle:  Angle just last week “banned” two TV stations from her election party “after their reporters surprised her with questions at the airport.”
  5. Delaware Senate candidate Christine O’Donnell: O’Donnell threatened to sue a Delaware radio station if it aired an interview with her.  She later apologized for the threat.

Many candidates are using social media networks like Facebook and Twitter,  their personal websites and specific media outlets, to interact with the public, The Times noted.  However, “some politicians have taken their distaste and mistrust of journalists a step further, opening a direct assault on the news media as an institution.”  (For example, see here PBS MediaShift’s Nov. 2009 story reporting how politicians are using social media to “deliver an uncensored, unfiltered — and unchecked — message.”

Nicolle Wallace, who is “a former communications strategist for George W. Bush and John McCain” told the Times, “The relationship is probably at a low point between politicians and the media, particularly on the right.” Wallace noted Sarah Palin “is at war with the media.”

As iMediaEthics has previously reported, Palin continues to slam the media’s reports that use anonymous sources, notably Vanity Fair’s largely anonymously-sourced profile and Politico’s Oct. 21 article “Hurricane Sarah.”

As evidence of their overall point, The New York Times also cited Pew Research Center’s 2009 poll on public attitudes toward the media.

“Whether it’s the press, whether it’s government, there has been this lowering of credibility in a lot of institutions in America,” Pew associate director Michael Dimock is quoted as saying. “You name it. It’s hard to find a group or institution that isn’t being viewed more skeptically these days.”

The 2009 press accuracy rating survey reported why people said they are critical of the media.  The following reasons were selected:

  • Biased
  • Can’t admit error
  • Not independent of “powerful people/organizations”
  • Not professional
  • Factually inaccurate

Submit a tip / Report a problem

New York Times: Politicians Boiling Mad at Media

Share this article: