VP Mike Pence replaced by Lt Gen McMaster? Not fake news, Texas-size front page error - iMediaEthics

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Apologies & Retractions»

The Eagle's front-page error. (Credit: The Eagle/Newseum)

The Bryan-College Station Eagle, a daily newspaper in Texas, published a story with a faulty headline that said Lt. Gen. H.R. McMaster was chosen to replace Vice President Mike Pence.

Wrong. McMaster was selected to replace Gen. Michael T. Flynn as President Trump’s National Security Adviser after Flynn resigned earlier this month.

Readers accused the paper of publishing “fake news,” but it really was just human error on display, the newspaper’s editor Kelly Brown told iMediaEthics by e-mail.

The daily newspaper’s headline read “Trump tabs McMaster to replace Pence.”

The paper has received dozens of phone calls and e-mails, Brown told iMediaEthics.

The Eagle is a Berkshire Hathaway-owned newspaper in Bryan, Texas, with a circulation of about 22,000, according to Mondo Times.

The Eagle's front page . Click to enlarge. (Credit: The Eagle/Newseum)

The Eagle‘s front page . Click to enlarge. (Credit: The Eagle/Newseum)

“The criticism has been fairly hostile and jumps directly to the ‘fake news’ or false accusation of being the bias liberal media,” Brown told iMediaEthics. “A few have been simply critical, as in ‘how can you be so stupid?’ Several demanded we fire the copy editor responsible; one contacted the CEO of BH Media (our owners) in Nebraska.”

What happened?

In her e-mail to iMediaEthics, Brown explained it was an error made by a copy editor who wrote the headline.

“The Eagle’s mistake was not a deliberate untruth or an alternative truth,” she wrote in an apology on the Eagle’s website. “It was an error made on deadline without enough back-up to catch the oversight. That falls on me.”

More specifically, the newspaper is short staffed for its “rover” position (which helps out on the copy desk and with other work around the newsroom). Only one copy editor  — the one who made the error — saw the headline that made it into print. That copy editor was the only copy editor working that night and since another editor was out for family reasons, the mistake slipped through.

To prevent future editing errors, Brown said the paper now will require the headlines on every page be checked by “at least three people.” The paper is currently short an editor, so that “means longer days for the managing editor and myself.”

“The solution for now, we hope, means more work for management rather than burden already overworked staffers,” Brown e-mailed iMediaEthics.

In a lengthy apology on its website, the Eagle’s editor Brown conceded, “There’s no good excuse at all for serving this to our readers.”

Some readers have responded with support for the newspaper, Brown told iMediaEthics by e-mail.

“Strangers, sources, friends and colleagues from across the country sent me emails or texts of support,” she added. “In general, the notes suggested taking responsibility and apologizing added to our credibility.”

In her apology on the Eagle’s website, Brown promised the paper “will do better” by putting “more eyes on every story, every cutline, every photo, every headline” and offered to discuss the mistake with any reader who wanted.


Submit a tip / Report a problem

VP Mike Pence replaced by Lt Gen McMaster? Not fake news, Texas-size front page error

Share this article: