The New York Post reported recently that a Chinese man named Feng Jian’s lawsuit against his wife for giving birth to an ugly child. The story claimed that Feng said he was tricked by his wife because she had had a ton of plastic surgery before meeting him and didn’t tell him.
But, the story has been debunked as “probably false” by urban legend website Snopes, Jim Romenesko reported. Several other outlets that have reported on the claims have backtracked to acknowledge that the story is probably phony. Snopes pointed to a 2004 story from the Heilongjiang Morning Post about Feng’s lawsuit.
Further, Snopes noted that the image used to accompany the lawsuit report shows a couple with “three children, the eldest of which is a boy.” And, the picture has been used as a Taiwan plastic surgery ad.
The New York Post has since added a clarification to its report, acknowledging the story has been questioned but standing by it. It reads:
“Clarification: Reports of Feng’s lawsuit against his wife were originally reported in European and US newspapers in 2004, but with no details of any adjudication or payout. While many have cast doubt on the wild tale, details of an alleged civil settlement were reported on Chinese Web sites last year and English-language media this week.”
However, the New York Post was likely just making excuses, iMediaEthics found. We followed the trail to see where this story came from — see what we found below.
What is the sourcing for the lawsuit’s claim?
The New York Post listed the source of its story as China’s Sina News. iMediaEthics searched Sina‘s website for “Feng Jian” and had no results. Not promising.
But, the Post claimed that recently “details of an alleged civil settlement were reported.” So we checked out what English-language media have been reporting on Feng’s story to see if the Post’s excuse carried any weight.
What did we find?
- The only English-language news story from the past few months about Feng’s lawsuit being successful came from News Net 5. (Other reports note the story is likely a hoax.)
- But, that story was published on a Tampa Bay news website back in 2012
- The story was sourced to the Irish Times, but iMediaEthics didn’t find any stories on Feng on the Irish Times website
- Instead,The Irish Examiner appears to be the actual source of the story, but its story’s sourcing is also questionable.
- The Irish Examiner story is sourced to a blog called Planet Ivy, which was based on a Philippines news site’s story, which was based on a Macedonian news site’s story, which had no source.
This month, the International Business Times reported on Feng Jian’s lawsuit, but it acknowledged in its story that the story “may be a hoax.”
Last year, the Huffington Post reported on the lawsuit but later admitted the story was “probably a hoax.” The Huffington Post story and a separate 2012 story by the Daily Mail both sourced their reports to Denver Fox-affiliate KDVR TV.
But, KDVR has added an editor’s note to its story about it being a hoax. The Oct. 2012 story, “Chinese man sues wife for being ugly, wins $120,000,” reads:
“EDITOR’S NOTE: This original story was sourced to MSN, who has since deleted their story. According to Snopes.com, this story has since been identified as a hoax.”
NewsNet 5 and Tampa Bay’s ABC Action News both published a story about Feng’s lawsuit. These stories were the same and both carried the byline “TheIndyChannel.com.” Oddly, NewsNet5’s story says it was published this month, and ABC Action News’ story says it was published Nov. 2012.
The ABC Action News story appears to be the only recent English-language news story on Feng’s alleged victorious lawsuit that hasn’t been retracted or clarified as possibly fake.
iMediaEthics searched TheIndyChannel.com’s website to find its original story. But, we ran into a dead end: there were no results for “Feng Jian.” TheIndyChannel.com’s Director of New Media Glen Hale told iMediaEthics by e-mail that the article did appear on its website but was written by “Internet Broadcasting, a web content provider we were affiliated with until the end of 2012.”
The IndyChannel.com story was sourced to The Irish Times. But, again, when iMediaEthics searched The Irish Times website, we hit another dead end because we didn’t find any story results for “Feng Jian.” The Irish Times confirmed to iMediaEthics that it didn’t have any story on Feng in its archive.
However, The Irish Examiner did write about the story in Oct. 2012 and included the quotes that the IndyChannel.com story had attributed to the Irish Times. The Week reported on The Irish Examiner’s story last year. (iMediaEthics has reached out to the Irish Times to confirm that it didn’t report on Feng.)
From here, iMediaEthics tracked down where the Irish Examiner story came from. The Irish Examiner story was sourced to blog PlanetIvy.com, which said it got the story from InterAksyon. InterAksyon, which identified itself as “the online news portal of TV5” in Manila, then sourced its story to Macedonian International News Agency.
The Macedonian International News Agency story, “Chinese Man Sues Wife for Being Ugly, and Wins,” from Feb. 28 2012, doesn’t carry any sourcing.
UPDATE: 11/11/2013 9:59 AM EST: Updated above with responses from the Irish Times and TheIndyChannel.com