MSNBC News Headline feed links to Sen Gillibrand campaign ad on iGoogle

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Advertising Disclosures»

HAPPY ACCIDENT? Was it a Google or MSNBC business news feed snafu that allowed New York's U.S. Senate appointee Kirsten Gillibrand's campaign ad to appear as an news headline on my iGoogle page?

When business news headlines appear on my iGoogle page, I expect links to MSNBC news content–not to an advertisement for a  U.S. Senate campaign.

But there it was last week. When I clicked on the headline “Presented By” for the “ U.S. Business,” I found, instead of a news story, Senator Hillary Clinton’s controversial replacement, Kirsten Gillibrand, seeking my vote.

I have contacted, MSNBC, Google and the Sen. Gillibrand’s office to find out what exactly went wrong that would transform a purchased ad into a MSNBC news headline? Was something even considered “wrong,” from the viewpoint of MSNBC or Google? If the answer to the latter question is “no,” and this was not a snafu, we are further down the slippery slope of news conflated with undisclosed advertising content.

Surprise! Your iGoogle page has news headlines that lead to ads is NOT what I had in mind while customizing content for my iGoogle page.

Here is the full screen shot of the Gillibrand ad and my iGoogle page where the “Presented By” link to the ad appeared.

UPDATE: It’s 1:58 pm. I just received this email response from Anne Espiritu, Google media representative: “Thanks for your inquiry.   You’ll periodically find ads in 3rd party gadgets —  particularly in the canvas-view mode. In terms of this ad in particular, I encourage you to contact MSNBC which has control over the content displayed on their gadget.”

I am still waiting for and Sen. Gillibrand’s office to respond.  It should be noted that was the most popular news web site in July 2005 with 27.4 million users. continues as number 1 in 2008.

UPDATE: 3:36pm : Just heard from Gina Stikes from, who writes: ” I’ve reached out to the team here and will provide you with an answer as soon as I have one for you.”

UPDATE: 3:44pm : My iGoogle page suddenly has a new issue oriented ad for Gillibrand that is also deceptively presented to readers as a news headline story using the same, “Presented By”  link. Here’s the ad.

Gadget malfunction or not…Gillibrand’s campaign benefits from’s huge web audience that continually checks their news headlines…but whoops it’s a campaign ad. Vote Gillibrand.

Submit a tip / Report a problem

MSNBC News Headline links to Kirsten Gillibrand campaign ad on iGoogle

Share this article:

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *