Atlanta Journal-Constitution Ending Public Editor Position, Splitting Up 'D

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Media's Future»

(Credit: Atlanta Journal-Constitution, screenshot)

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution is ending its public editor position, according to a May 25 column by its outgoing public editor Shawn McIntosh.

McIntosh wrote that she is leaving the position for a “new role supervising watchdog and investigative coverage,” and that she won’t “be replaced with a new public editor.”

“Instead, we’re asking our entire newsroom leadership team to take on some of the public editor duties of listening to readers and responding to their concerns.”

According to her public LinkedIn profile, McIntosh has been the public editor since April 2009, after nine months as the newspaper’s “deputy managing editor/News and Information.”   Her predecessors include Matt Kempner and Mike King.

We wrote to the Organization of News Ombudsman’s executive director, Jeffrey Dvorkin, asking how many ombudsmen are left in the U.S. (McIntosh was listed as one of ten U.S. memberson the organization’s website.)  Dvorkin explained “I think 9 is the correct number. We are in the process of determining the nature of full membership, associate membership and affiliated membership.” (Disclosure: iMediaEthics‘ publisher, Rhonda Roland Shearer, is an associate member of the organization andattended the annual ONO conference in Copenhagen last month.)

According to Dvorkin, the role of ombudsmen has been changing.  He wrote:

“Ombudsmen are no longer the somewhat isolated figures of even a few years ago. Some do work for their media that includes handling letters to the editor and other tasks related to relations with the public. The media business is changing rapidly and so should the definition of what a news ombudsman does. ”

Dvorkin noted that former Australian Broadcasting Corporation ombudsman Murray Green is reviewing “ONO’s statutes and by-laws” for updating.

We have written to McIntosh twice asking about her role as public editor, the decision to end the position and how the position will be divided among the “newsroom leadership team.” We will update with any response. We have also written to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution‘s media contact asking about this change and will update with any response.

UPDATED: 6/7/2012 11:27 AM EST: We heard back from the Atlanta Journal-Constitution’s consumer marketing manager Drue Miller who provided us with the Atlanta Journal-Constitution’s answers to our questions.

According to the AJC‘s response, the newspaper set up a public editor role in 2000 and that the role is being ended because: “The newsroom leadership team decided that funneling all reader input through a single source no longer makes sense with so many feedback channels for readers. While there will not be a single dedicated public editor, the newsroom will still respond to reader feedback.”

We also asked how the job will be split among “newsroom leadership” and who will handle what duties and were told “The three managing editors will respond to reader concerns in their area and McIntosh will continue to coordinate reader research. “

Submit a tip / Report a problem

Public Editor Role Ended at Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Share this article:

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *