Bloggers are accusing the fashion magazine of lightening Sidibe’s skin. Also, ELLE has been criticized for tightly cropping Sidibe’s photo to only show her face, while the other three covers show most of the cover models’ bodies.
ELLE’s October issue is available with four alternate covers — each featuring a different person considered notable. The other three cover women are reality TV star Lauren Conrad and actresses Amanda Seyfried and Megan Fox, all 24-years-old.
The blog Womanist Musings is credited with first questioning the photos in its Sept 13 post. “Photoshopping is quite common in magazines, but when they chose to lighten a dark-skinned Black woman, it is racist no matter what the original intent was.”
“Nothing out of the ordinary was done. We have four separate covers this month and Gabby’s cover was not retouched any more or less than the others. We had 25 cover-worthy subjects in our portfolio and we chose Gabby because of who she is. We shot this as a story of exuberant young women changing the world. If you take a look at the portfolio, each of the women were shot in different ways and for different reasons.”
Further, ELLE’s editor-in-chief, Robbie Myers, says “it’s not a controversy,” E! News reported. “What’s so sad about it is that people have not looked at anything else but this. There’s an incredible portfolio inside that Joe [Zee] and Carter [Smith] shot . They haven’t looked at it. People want to make something out of nothing. It’s sad the legitimate news media picks up on this.”
“It sort of boils down to this,” Myers explained. “At a photo shoot, in a studio, that is a fashion shoot, that’s glamorous, the lighting is different. The photography is different than a red carpet shot from a paparazzi.”
She emphasized, “We absolutely did not lighten her skin. Retouching is when we take a piece of hair and move it out of her eye, so you can’t compare a picture on a press line from what you do in a studio, where your job is to make them look beautiful. This is their controversy. We’ve seen these things before. I am sad that no one has cracked the magazine and looked at it. We gave her a cover, and she loved it.”
Sidibe’s representative seemingly didn’t address whether the photo was lightened or not, as her representative is quoted as saying in response to the controversy that “Gabourey is absolutely thrilled to be on the cover of the magazine’s 25th anniversary issue.”