Do Leaked Fox News E-mails Show Training in Biased Reporting?

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Bias»

See screen shot detail above of a leaked Fox News e-mail from Fox News' Washington managing editor Bill Sammon. (Credit: Media Matters)

Media Matters, the progressive media watchdog website, published leaked e-mails from Fox News that suggest an editorial decision to “slant” health care language, Seattle PI reported.

In the leaked Fox News e-mails, from Fox News’ Washington managing editor Bill Sammon and senior vice president for news Michael Clemente, the two train staff members to use on-air terminology reportedly linked to conservatives.  (See the e-mails on Media Matters’ website here.)

An Oct. 27 e-mail from Sammon advises staff to “use the term ‘government-run health insurance” as opposed to “public option.”

When using the term “public option,” Sammon instructed staffers “use the qualifier ‘so-called.'”

In response, Clemente wrote thanking Sammon and advising that “The public option, which is the government-run plan,” is “the preferred way to say it, write it, use it.”

Government option is phrasing that Republican pollster Frank Luntz suggested, Media Matters reported.  Luntz had explained:

“‘If you call it a ‘public option,’ the American people are split,’ but that ‘if you call it the ‘government option,’ the public is overwhelmingly against it.”

Sammon explained the e-mail in an interview with The Daily Beast’s Howard Kurtz.

Sammon reportedly reasoned that the “public option” phrase “is a vague, bland, undescriptive phrase.”  According to Sammon, Kurtz reported, “government-run plan” is “a more neutral term.”

Further, Sammon claimed:  “I have no idea what the Republicans were pushing or not. It’s simply an accurate, fair, objective term.”

Sammon also asserted that he has been neutral and has 25 years experience as a reporter.  However, Kurtz noted that in the past year, “Sammon has been notably unsympathetic to the Obama administration” in Fox appearances.

New York Magazine questioned: “So was Sammon’s memo an example of the network catering to GOP talking points? He’s got decent cover” by saying that “government-run plan” is clearer than public option.  However, New York Magazine doubted that the terminology shift wasn’t partisan related, given the addition of “so-called” to a “policy that liberals are championing.”

iMediaEthics is writing Fox News for further comment.

Submit a tip / Report a problem

Do Leaked Fox News E-mails Show Training in Spin & Biased Reporting?

Share this article: