Australian Shark Photo a Fake, News Duped by Photoshopped Selfie - iMediaEthics

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Fact Checking»

Alex Hayes posted this doctored image to his Instagram. Social media and news sites posted it as real.

Fake shark photo alert! An Australian teenager did NOT get a great selfie with a shark while surfing.

The teenager, Alex Hayes, posted the shark photo on Instagram, writing that he “went for a paddle” and took a picture with his GoPro after seeing a “chiller” shark “just cruisin.”

“Pretty much everyone fell for it,” Hayes told iMediaEthics by e-mail. “It is fake.”

“We thought it was pretty obvious, but since no one questioned it we just rolled with it,” he added.  And if people asked if it was fake, I would tell them but since no one asked, was pretty easy.” He said if anyone asked him about the photo in person he would “just change the subject” to avoid questions, but when the “media eventually started to question it” he answered media questions.

“It’s just a funny photo that was meant to be just a huge joke that has caused humour and discussion in the media,” Hayes added.

“It just went super viral so quickly,” Hayes wrote. “I didn’t expect that at all, but it’s good now that the awareness of sharks not all being dangerous has become a part of the subject because they are all beautiful creatures! We live in a beautiful place and we share it with some pretty cool animals, so I’m happy.”

See below a screenshot of the shark photo, posted June 10, to Hayes’ Instagram account.

Alex Hayes, Instagram, surfer, gopro, shark, shark photo

A screenshot from Alex Hayes’ Instagram account


Who was Duped?

The UK Independent published a report on the photo as if it were real but it has since apparently deleted the story. A Google search still produces a story about Hayes and the photo but when you click on the link it redirects to the homepage.



Yahoo 7 News posted a June 13 story, “Bold Sydney teen snaps Great White selfie.”

The UK Mirror’s June 14 story was headlined, “Australian teen surfer posts picture of ‘shark selfie’ – but is it too good to be true?” The Mirror noted the photo could be “too good to be true” and “some claim it is a fake.”

Daily Mail Australia’s June 12 story is titled, “‘He was just cruisin’: Nonchalant teen surfer spots a huge shark under his board… so he grabs his gopro and SNAPS a selfie.” The Mail even worked in a Kim Kardashian reference in its lede.

daily mail, gopro, shark photo, selfie, surfer, australia

(Credit: Daily Mail, screenshot)


Pedestrian TV also covered the photo as if it were real, with the story “STRAYA: SURFER SEES SHARK UNDERNEATH HIS BOARD, TAKES SELFIE.”

Surfing Life ran “Alex Hayes sees shark, takes selfie.

TV New Zealand published a June 14 story headlined, “‘He was a chiller’ – Aussie teen snaps selfie with huge shark.”

Hat Tip:


Submit a tip / Report a problem

Australian Shark Photo a Fake, News Duped by Photoshopped Selfie

Share this article:

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *