Did Medium (Over)Aggregate or Plagiarize The Week? Atlantic Editor Points

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.

Menu

Home » Plagiarism»

A screenshot from Medium's post. (Credit: Medium, screenshot)

The Atlantic senior editor Alexis Madrigal wondered if San Francisco-based media website Medium stole a story from the website for NYC-based magazine The Week or if it was an example of bad aggregating.

iMediaEthics took a look at the two stories after seeing Madrigal’s tweet. In our opinion, Medium‘s post barely re-writes and definitely over-aggregates The Week‘s post.

Medium did sort of indicate to readers that The Week inspired the post with a note at the bottom of its post saying “(via The Week)” but in iMediaEthics’ opinion, it wasn’t nearly sufficient.  Readers of Medium‘s post wouldn’t know from that tiny hat tip that Medium didn’t just get the idea for the post from The Week but actually took the entire post from the magazine. The Week‘s June 27 post was 681words and Medium‘s August 14 was 220 words.

Below, we highlighted some sections of the two posts to show how similar they are.

The Week‘s headline was “4 changes to English so subtle we hardly notice they’re happening” whereas Medium went for a simple: “How English is Changing.”  Medium took the four points raised by The Week and barely re-wrote them. While it’s not really a straight up copy and paste job, the words and phrasing are similar. We used different colored highlighting to point similar areas Medium‘s post is to The Week. Compare red with red, and green with green and so on.

For example, from The Week‘s original post:

“SHIFT FROM “THEY STARTED TO WALK” TO “THEY STARTED WALKING”
“There are a number of verbs that can take a complement with another verb in either the “-ing” form or the “to” form: “They liked painting/to paint;” “We tried leaving/to leave;” “He didn’t bother calling/to call.” Both of these constructions are still used, and they have both been used for a long time. But there has been a steady shift over time from the “to” to the “-ing” complement. “Start” and “begin” saw a big increase in the “-ing” complement until leveling out in the 1940s, whiles emotion verbs like “like,” “love,” “hate,” and “fear” saw their proportion of “-ing” complements start to rise in the 1950s and 60s. Not all verbs have participated in the shift: “stand,” “intend,” and “cease” went the “to” way.”

And from Medium:

“They started to walk” is turning into “they started walking:”
Verbs are steadily transitioning from the “to” to the “-ing” ending. Before the forties, “start” and “begin” saw a big increase in the “-ing” form, while in the fifties and sixties, verbs such as “like,” “love,” “hate,” and “fear” underwent the same rise in popularity. On the other hand, verbs like “stand,” “intend,” and “cease” shifted more toward the “to” form.”

For one more example:

From The Week:

“3. GOING TO, HAVE TO, NEED TO, WANT TO
It’s pretty noticeable that words like “shall” and “ought” are on the way out, but “will,” “should,” and “can” are doing just fine. There are other members of this helping verb club though, and they have been on a steep climb this century. “Going to,” “have to,” “need to,” and “want to” cover some of the same meaning territory as the other modal verbs. They first took hold in casual speech and have enjoyed a big increase in print in recent decades.”

And from Medium:

“Going to,” “have to,” “need to,” and “want to: Helping verbs such as these have surged in the past few decades. First used in casual conversation, this verb group eventually entered print, which contributed to its rise.”

When iMediaEthics checked Medium’s website around 3:35 PM, the story in question was suddenly missing and the link went to an error page. See below our screenshot of the post

iMediaEthics asked Okrent if she had any comment on Medium’s handling of her story and if she thought it was an acceptable aggregation. Okrent responded via email:  “Yeah, I definitely wouldn’t have done it like that. I appreciate the catch.”

We’ve also reached out to Medium for comment. We’ll update with any response.

UPDATE: 8/14/2013 3:50 PM EST: Added a screenshot of the post.

UPDATE: 8/14/2013 5:00 PM EST: Added info about Medium and The Week

UPDATE: 8/14/2013 9:13 PM EST: Added response from Okrent.

Submit a tip / Report a problem

Did Medium ‘(Over)Aggregate’ or Plagiarize The Week? Atlantic Editor Points out Aggregation Issues

Share this article:

คาสิโน
สล็อต
sa gaming
tkb365
https://tkb399.com/login
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต
ทำความรู้จักกับ
PG
สล็อต
tkb138
sa gaming
https://www.hotelplayagolf.com/es/instalaciones/piscinas
tkb365
บาคาร่า
สล็อตเว็บตรง
บาคาร่า
ทดลองเล่นสล็อตฟรี
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต pg
สล็อตเว็บตรง
สล็อตเว็บตรง
tkb138
ซุปเปอร์สล็อต
tkb138
tkb365
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต
changbet789
สูตรสล็อต pg ทดลองเล่นฟรี
สล็อต ดาวน์โหลด รับเครดิตฟรี
สล็อต
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต
tkb138
https://www.hotelalbora.com/
https://tkb108.co/register
tkb696
สล็อตเว็บตรง
changbet789
สล็อตทดลอง
pg
betflix
pg slot
สล็อต
pg slot
สล็อตเว็บจริง100%
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต
sbobet
บาคาร่า
tkb138
https://titanium-hotel.com/
สล็อต
tkb138
taokaebet
tkb777
อันดับแรก
คาสิโน
changbet789
แจกเครดิตฟรี 100%
ทดลองเล่นสล็อตทุกค่ายฟรี
สล็อต
changbet789
tkb365
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต
changbet789
finfinbet
คาสิโน
changbet789
tkb108
tkbneko
สล็อตเว็บตรง
สล็อต
สล็อต
สล็อต
https://www.gday96.com/
สล็อต888
สล็อต
PG
บาคาร่าเว็บตรง
changbet789
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต pg
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต
ทดลองเล่นสล็อตฟรี
tkb365
tkb365
tkb365
tkb555
tkb555
tkb555
tkb555
tkb555
tkb555
tkb555
tkbking
tkbking
tkbking
tkbking
tkbking
tkbking
thb889
thb889
thb889
thb889
thb889
thb889
thb889
tkb4
tkb4
tkb4
tkb4
tkb4
tkb4
tkb4
tkb9
tkb9
tkb9
tkb9
tkb9
tkb9
tkb9
tkb33
tkb33
tkb33
tkb33
tkb33
tkb33
tkb33
finfinbet
finfinbet
finfinbet
finfinbet
finfinbet
finfinbet
finfinbet
TKB96
tkb96
tkb96
tkb96
tkb96
tkb96
tkb96
tkbfun
tkbfun
tkbfun
tkbfun
tkbfun
tkbfun
tkbfun
tkbpg
tkbpg
tkbpg
tkbpg
tkbpg
tkbpg
tkbpg
tkbpussy
tkbpussy
tkbpussy
tkbpussy
tkbpussy
tkbpussy
tkbpussy
tkbrich
tkbrich
tkbrich
tkbrich
tkbrich
tkbrich
tkbrich
tkbsexy
tkbsexy
tkbsexy
tkbsexy
tkbsexy
tkbsexy
tkb777
tkb777
tkb777
tkb777
tkb777
tkb777
tkb777
taokaebet
taokaebet
taokaebet
taokaebet
taokaebet
taokaebet
taokaebet
tkbsexy
tkbrich
tkbpussy
tkbpg
tkbfun
tkb96
tkb33
tkb9
tkb4
thb889
tkbking
tkb555
tkb365
changbet789
บาคาร่า
คาสิโนออนไลน์
sa gaming
คาสิโนออนไลน์สด
สล็อต
สล็อต
สล็อตเว็บตรง
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต pg ซื้อฟรีสปิน
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต
บาคาร่า
สล็อต เว็บตรงไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์ไม่มีขั้นต่ำ
ทดลองเล่นสล็อต
สล็อต
สล็อต
บาคาร่า
สล็อต
สล็อต
สล็อต
คาสิโน