Did Fake Photo Win National Geo Photo Contest ?

Home » Fake Photos»

Did Shibnath Basu from India enter the 2008 National Geographic photo contest after using Photoshop to create his winning image? National Geographic is investigating.

Shibnath Basu from India entered what many think was a fake photo in the 2008 International Photography Contest at National Geographic–and won “Viewers’ Choice.” Once his alleged deception was reported on Photoshopdisasters, National Geographic withdrew the photo without comment or correction on the contest page.

Basu’s caption said, “These shallow waters are mainly famous for flamingos at Nal Sarovar near Ahmedabad,Gujarat, India. The picture shows the reflection of clouds on water.”

Even though Photoshopdisasters declared the image a fake, Ellen Stanley, Vice President, Communications said they are still investigating and sent StinkyJournalism a statement.

It said, “The International Photography Contest from National Geographic has sparked unparalleled interest from photographers around the world, with some 220,000 submissions this year worldwide. The rules of the competition clearly state that no altered images can be submitted. It has come to our attention that one of the Viewers’ Choice winners of the English-language competition might be an altered image. When we asked our panel of photography experts to review it, they believed it to be questionable. To give the photographer the benefit of the doubt, we asked him to send us the source negative, which we have not yet received. For now, we will remove the image from the Web site until the matter is resolved.” A Dec 17 blog post by Rob Covey on Nat Geo web site repeats this same official statement.

iMediaEthics will let readers know about the outcome of Nat Geo’s investigation.

Submit a tip / Report a problem

National Geographic investigates Photo Contest Winner:

Share this article:

4 Responses

  1. Shawn says:

    Has anyone else noticed that the clouds in the water are not a reflection of, but a continuation of the cloud? It’s obviously a fake. Again, the images do not "mirror" each other.

  2. Guest says:

    of course its a fake !!!!!!!!!!!!! the clouds have ZERO reflexion in the water !! its a straight image with a horizon line going through the middle!

  3. Ron Mellott says:

    When has anyone ever seen clouds approach the horizon line as depicted in this image and just disappear into the water? Anyone that spends time outdoors knows: that just does not occur. Also, with whater that still (assuming it was that still) should a mirror reflection, which it is not. PLUS: the reflection of the person on the right shows the reflection is moving, not sharp. So, why would the clouds be as spectacularly sharp in the reflection as in the sky?

  4. Ryan Carter says:

    I love this photo, but it is obviously a photoshop creation. A rather happy mistake if you ask me, very surreal.

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *