Fred Thompson Remains Number 1 Presidential Candidate in the Newsweek Article Race

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Bias»

If the number of Newsweek articles were the measure of who will be US President, Fred Thompson has already won.

Even though his campaign only officially started a month ago, on September 5, when he declared his candidacy on the NBC Tonight Show, he has been cast by Newsweek as a serious presidential hopeful in 19 stories, from March 2007 to mid-October 2007 according to our recent study. Hillary and Obama had less coverage, by almost half (10 articles each) during the same time period. Mike Huckabee eked out just one Newsweek report. We further contrasted Thompson’s coverage with other, lesser known, but declared candidates who’ve been running hard in both parties – Dennis Kucinich, say, or Joe Biden, or Bill Richardson – and we were surprised they had gotten zero coverage.

Before delving into our findings, the fundamental ethical principle at stake here needs to be mentioned.Why did Newsweek editors judge Thompson most worthy among all candidates in both parties to receive this favoritism in coverage?

The possible answer lies in the perception, if not the actuality of, a conflict of interest.  Newsweek’s editorial love affair with Fred Thompson may be related to Newsweek’s undisclosed “business partnership” with NBC, Thompson’s employer.

After all, our other study shows that Time Magazine, Newsweek’s competitor, only published 4 stories on Thompson while Newsweek published 19 reports of questionable news value.  Nowhere in any of Newsweek’s coverage do they disclose that Thompson is an NBC employee and that NBC is their partner and, up until this week, host of their MSNBC/MSN website.

An informed citizenry needs a “comprehensive” and “proportionate” press

Media ethicists Bill Kovach and Tom Rosenstiel, in their book “The Elements of Journalism,” cite as their “eighth principle” of a free press the need for journalists to “keep the news comprehensive and in proportion.”

Informed citizens need comprehensive and proportional coverage to make good voting decisions. And by most informal measures, we’re a grossly uninformed lot. NBC’s Today Show, for example, recently aired a segment in which random people were shown photographs of various “second-tier” candidates. It all made for good television fun when it was revealed that most of the respondents did not know Dennis Kucinich or Sam Brownback from Adam.

Maybe the joke is not on citizens. Maybe the joke is on the mainstream media outlets that have offered such anemic coverage of the majority of candidates.

Continue Reading - Pages: 1 2 View All

Submit a tip / Report a problem

iMediaEthics Study: Fred Thompson Finishes 1st with 19 stories in Newsweek

Share this article:

3 Responses

  1. The ASRLAB STAFF says:

    Let us know what you think of the alleged FCC efforts to cut back cross ownership restrictions?

    Give us your feedback and suggestions. Thank you for your visit.

  2. Your Useful Idiots says:

    I was hoping to come to your website to find some useful and objective information. Now I can take you off my list as yet another propganda machine for the useful idiots you play to.

    You slam Newsweek as “favoring” someone simply by the total number of articles, ignoring content or volume. That’s real analysis! Give me a break.

  3. Rhonda R. Shearer says:

    Dear "Your Useful Idiots", Thanks for your comment. The fact of 19 articles for Thompson and 0 articles for 10 viable GOP and DEMs candidates, we felt was significant and extreme no matter the length or content. However, with that said, we still provided all 19 articles and mentioned they are lite on news worthiness. SJ Readers have the opportunity to judge for themselves.

    I am sure the 11 candidates that received NO coverage in Newsweek would have appreciated even one article, of any length or content, during the same time period Thompson inexplicably got 19 articles. Alas, they did not have that opportunity.

    Frankly speaking, giving Thompson 19 articles, most of which were done before he was a declared candidate, while giving other viable, declared candidates many less seems even on its face, unfair.

    We try to use facts (counts of articles) as a objective means to measure bias.

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *