Was Associated Press Sherrod Brown Pic Photoshopped for Political Ad?

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Fake Photos»

See the advertisement's picture on the left, and the Associated Press's photo on the right. (Credit: The Hill.com)

Did the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Photoshop an Associated Press photo of U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown (D-OH)?

According to Talking Points Memo, Ohio Democrats allege that the chamber of Commerce’s “attack ad” features an AP photo doctored to show Brown unshaven. The website for the Ohio Democratic Party (see here) shows a side-by-side comparison of the AP photo and a screenshot from the advertisement.  It appears that they are the same photo, with the exception of the advertisement adding scruff to Brown’s face.

TheHill.com notes that the Associated Press photo was taken “in July 2006 outside a steel mill in Middletown, Ohio.”  Besides the added facial hair, the advertisement photo features a different background and resembles “surveillance-camera footage.”

According to Cincinnati.com, the party issued a press release commenting that ““Apparently not content with simply distorting Sherrod’s record, they’ve even taken  to distorting his picture.”  The party also claimed that the advertisement contains fake claims.

The Chamber of Commerce has released ads promoting four Republicans (three congressmen, one senator) and ads “slamming” Brown and Jon Tester (D-Montana), according to TheHill.com.  Republican Josh Mandel, currently Ohio’s state treasurer, is Brown’s opponent in the 2012 race.

In response to criticism, a spokesperson for the Chamber of Commerce, J.P. Fielder, is quoted by Cincinnati.com as saying  “I don’t have an answer to where the photo was changed, or if it was.” Fielder claimed that Brown is “running away from his record.”

See the advertisment here on Cleveland Scene.

Cincinnati.com noted that Brown’s wife, Connie Schultz, called the photo “fake” and “altered” in a Facebook post.

We wrote in September when Schultz, at the time a columnist for the Cleveland Plain Dealer, issued an apology for videotaping but not reporting on Josh Mandel, her husband’s opponent in the race.

She resigned from the Plain Dealer later that month because of the conflict of interest her marraige to Brown, who is seeking re-election, raises, as we wrote.

We are writing to the Associated Press and the Chamber of Commerce  for comment. We will update with any response.

Submit a tip / Report a problem

Was Associated Press Pic Photoshopped for Political Ad?

Share this article: