Rotten Apple Story: Mainstream Media needs to learn from Jobs Rumor

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Fact Checking»

Mainstream Media--not bloggers--were responsible for the bad Apple story.

Mainstream media (MsM) has tried to blame bloggers for the publication of a false rumor that made Apple stocks tumble.

James Callan,, wrote, “CNN’s plunge into online citizen- journalism backfired yesterday when the cable-news outlet posted what turned out to be a bogus report claiming that Apple Inc. Chief Executive Officer Steve Jobs had suffered a heart attack.”

Callen continued, “Apple shares fell as much as 5.4 percent after the post on CNN’s and rebounded after the Cupertino, California- based company said the story was false. CNN quickly disabled the user’s account and said it tried unsuccessfully to contact the individual.”

However, Greg Sandoval , CNet, reported the real story. It wasn’t bloggers fault. “The real reason it [the fraudulent story] gained traction is the reporting of it on mainstream blog sites.”

Sandoval continued. “What hasn’t been widely circulated yet is that iReport was not the first place the fake story was sent. Arnold Kim, who operates the blog,, wrote Friday that someone submitted the same rumor to his site using an anonymous IP address. Kim did some research on the rumor and decided it was a fake.”

“Kim from MacRumors argues,” Sandoval said, ” that it was SAI’s post that gave the rumor credibility and spooked Wall Street. ‘ The (iReport) story has been picked up by numerous sites as a failure of citizen journalism,’ Kim wrote. ‘ It’s nothing of the sort. The real reason it gained traction is the reporting of it on mainstream blog sites.’ “

The time line proves MsM –not bloggers– gave an unverified rumor oxygen by re-printing it from a mainstream media owned site–CNN iReports. CNN benefits from iReports, but unlike CNN employees’ content,  they claim they have no responsibly for accuracy. Bloomberg quoted CNN’s response to the debacle : “CNN has no plans to review its procedures for placing content on the iReport Web site.”

Leonard Witt, PJNet blogger, reported, “that an interview I conducted in July also challenged CNN iReport’s filtering. The interview entitled CNN iReport Superstar Tells All — Maybe Too Much contains this quote from iReport superstar Grayson Daughters:”

” The user can generate whatever they want to. It’s now up to the consumer to decide if they want to USE that media. Once you get into the user-generated realm, journalism ethics are going to very hard to apply to every user out there.”

Submit a tip / Report a problem

Rotten Apple Story: Steve Jobs Heart attack story fake

Share this article:

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *