NY Times Withdraws Fake Photos --No Explanation
BIG STORIES :
News Corp. | Phone Hacking Scandal | WikiLeaks | Barack Obama | Julian Assange | 2012 U.S. Election | Religion | See All
iMEDIAETHICS.org
Seperator
 
Tips Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter RSS Feeds
 
Home | | Contact Us

US Media Ethics News :
Daily Media Pick
Comments (2)
Print Tweet Email

NY Times Withdraws Fake Photos --No Explanation

By: Rhonda Roland Shearer
July 08, 2009 12:00 AM EST
 
NY Times Withdraws Fake Photos --No Explanation
 
New York Times Magazine withdrew images they published without explanation. (Elements from actual screen shot condensed above).
 

Blogger unixrat, in a Metafilter post titled, "Ruins of the Second Gilded Age," reported in the comments section his discovery that The New York Times inadvertently published Photoshopped images by Edgar Martins, a Portuguese photographer, in a Sunday Magazine photo essay, July 5.

The Times hired Martins, according to acb, the author of the original blog post, "to travel around the United States and take photographs of abandoned construction projects left in the wake of the housing and securities market collapse."

Among the 125 comments the post generated were links to numerous photos by Martins accompanied by devastating critiques by unixrat, Afroblanco and yoink that debunked any belief that these photos were anything other than doctored. Unixrat informed the Times of the deception. The Times quickly responded by pulling the entire photo gallery they had published online.

The problem remains that there is no mention or disclosure about unixrat's discovery, the Metafilter post or even a clear admission by The Times that the photos were removed because they are fakes. 

So I sent the following email to Clark Hoyt, New York Times Public Editor: Wed, 8 Jul 2009 06:28:53 am EST

Dear Mr. Hoyt,

I just ran across this withdrawal notice in a Times Magazine Image gallery.

"Editors' Note: July 7, 2009

"The pictures in this feature were removed after questions were raised about whether they had been digitally altered."

We are distressed that there is no transparency regarding what actually happened to these images. Obviously, The Times does not remove images just because "questions were raised." Readers need more than an inadequate placeholder when such drastic measures are taken as the actual withdrawal of published images. 

Please explain."  

StinkyJournalism is waiting for a response from the Times.     

UPDATE: 07/08/09 1:53pm EST : I added the time we emailed Mr. Hoyt--6:28am EST. We will soon include time stamps with dates to document when we post stories.

UPDATE: 07/08/09 3:26pm EST : There is an excellent post with technical analysis of the photo fakery on PDNPulse.com (Photo District News).

UPDATE: 07/08/09 3:55pm EST : Just got a comment from the NY Times Magazine's office: (Re Fakery?) "We are going to run an editor's note in an upcoming issue."

I am still pressing....

UPDATE: 07/08/09 4:38pm EST: MPR News: Public radio interview with unixrat --the blogger who discovered the fraud. (Hat tip: Editor&Publisher)

Line
Print   Print
Line
Twitter   Tweet
Report an Error Report an Error
Email   E-mail
Link Send a Tip
 

Just a note: the images are actually still up on the NYTimes website. Or, at least, they were last night, when I blogged about it. Only the slideshow entry was removed, not the photographs themselves.

Comment by Shannon Noelle | Jul 18, 2009 at 06:52 AM EST
 
 
  RESOURCES FOR EDUCATORS
 
Checkout iMediaEthics Resources for Educators, a helpful section for colleges, institutions, students and teachers.
Ethics Codes Case Studies Sites We Like
Ethics Codes Case Studies Sites We Like
 
   DAVID MOORE ON POLLS [See All]   
9 in 10 Americans can be classified as Racist against Either Blacks or Whites?  What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes really tells Us, Part 2.
PollSkeptic Report:   9 in 10 Americans can be classified as Racist...
What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes Really Tells Us, Part 1
PollSkeptic Report:   What the AP Poll on Racial Attitudes Really Tells...
David Moore
PollTalk Blog:   Why the Midterm Election Polls Stunk
   MORE BY THIS AUTHOR [See All]   
   SIMILAR TOPIC
 
$4 Chinese food overcharge leads to fake racist email, T-shirt sales by reporter and Boston.com retraction
$4 Chinese food overcharge leads to fake racist email, T-shirt sales by reporter and Boston.com retraction
Boston.com reporter Hilary Sargent was suspended and...
 
How did Fake Chinese News Site Dupe Washington Post, Atlantic, BBC?
How did Fake Chinese News Site Dupe Washington Post, Atlantic, BBC?
Multiple news outlets including the Washington Post and...
 
Fake Star Wars trailer dupes Rolling Stone, No Correction
Fake Star Wars trailer dupes Rolling Stone, No Correction
Rolling Stone was duped by a fake trailer for the new...
 
Russia's Channel 1 Airs Fake Malaysian Airlines 17 Crash Photo
Russia's Channel 1 Airs Fake Malaysian Airlines 17 Crash Photo
Russia's Channel 1 was hoaxed by a fake photo...
 
   TWITTER
   FACEBOOK
   LATEST STORIES [See All]