420 Complaints over BBC Interview, but no Investigation by Regulator

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Ombudsmen/Press Councils»

Ofcom received more than 400 complaints over a BBC interview with Jody McIntyre pictured above (Credit: YouTube, BBC)

A British communications regulator won’t be investigating a BBC interview that drew 420 complaints, Journalism.co.uk reported.

Despite the high number of complaints, the regulator, Ofcom, reportedly opted against looking into the interview of Jody McIntyre by Ben Brown on BBC News Dec. 13.  Ofcom is an “independent regulator and competition authority for the UK communications industries.”

Viewers reportedly complained that Brown “was too challenging in his interview, in particular when he asked McIntyre whether he had rolled towards the police in his wheelchair.”

McIntyre has cerebral palsy and uses a wheelchair.  During December student protests, he claims he was pulled out of his wheelchair by police and a video posted online is reported to show McIntyre being dragged out of his wheelchair.  McIntyre was at a “demonstration against student tuition fees.”

According to Journalism.co.uk, the BBC stated there were a “considerable number of complaints” over the interview.

According to Digital Spy, Brown asked McIntyre if he had been “‘wheeling’ himself toward police during the protest.”

McIntyre reportedly responded:

“I can’t physically use my wheelchair myself. My brother was pushing me. I think it was quite obvious from the footage that I was 100% not a threat to anyone…”

“Do you really think a person with cerebral palsy in a wheelchair can pose a threat to a police officer who is armed with weapons?””

However, BBC News’ controller, Kevin Bakhurst, reportedly stood by the interview when it aired.

Bakhurst is quoted as saying:

“I have reviewed the interview a few times and I would suggest that we interviewed Mr McIntyre in the same way that we would have questioned any other interviewee in the same circumstances: it was quite a long interview and Mr McIntyre was given several minutes of airtime to make a range of points, which he did forcefully; Ben challenged him politely but robustly on his assert.”

Digital Spy reported that an Ofcom spokesperson stated that Ofcom didn’t find the interview biased.

The spokesperson stated:

“People have said the interview was particularly aggressive towards a student.

“There were accusations of bias but we referred these to the BBC. Ofcom will not be investigating because we do not believe there has been a breach of the Broadcasting Code.”

iMediaEthics previously wrote about McIntyre in mid-December when more than 500 readers complained to the Press Complaints Commission about a Daily Mail column comparing McIntyre to a character on a sketch comedy show.

iMediaEthics is writing to Ofcom and McIntyre for comment.

UPDATE: 1/2/11: 10:07 AM EST: Added information about protests.

Submit a tip / Report a problem

BBC Jody McIntyre Interview Receives 420 Complaints but no Investigation by Regulator

Share this article:

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *