Graphic Video of Brazilian Transgender Woman being Beaten in Public Interest, Press Council says - iMediaEthics

iMediaEthics publishes international media ethics news stories and investigations into journalism ethics lapses.


Home » Ombudsmen/Press Councils»

Australian newspapers (Credit: Press Council video)

A Brazilian transgender woman was beaten to death in the streets in Brazil, and Australia’s captured the violence with a video and graphic still images. While the video was “substantially distressing,” the Australian Press Council ruled that publishing it was in the public interest.

Oddly, despite the ruling in’s favor, the article now doesn’t show any photos or videos. A press council spokesperson told iMediaEthics that took the graphic footage and images down this week but wasn’t required to. editor Kate De Brito told iMediaEthics the website was pleased with the ruling and the images and video were only removed because of a technical glitch. “The reason the pictures and video have disappeared is purely technical,” she explained. “We are required to update the original story with the Press Council logo and in updating the main picture container of an archived story it stripped out the video and pictures.”

“We did not remove the video or pictures for any other reason,” De Brito continued. “It’s kind of ironic though, isn’t it? A video triggers a reader complaint, we argue it is in the public interest, this is upheld by the Press Council, but then in communicating this to our readers the video has to go.”

The March 9 story, “Smartphone footage captures Brazilian transgender woman pleading for help prior to being beaten to death,” describes the video of the February incident in Brazil. The video was recorded on a phone and distributed to help find the woman’s attackers, who ultimately killed her.’s story noted that “globally, one transgender person is murdered every three days.”

“There is a public interest in reporting on the serious issue of violence towards transgender people worldwide and in providing access to reliable information demonstrating the due administration of justice,” the press council explained. Further, warned viewers with text warnings and a summary of the video, which helped mitigate the graphic nature of the video, and didn’t show the “most violent footage,” the council said.

That said, the warning on the video itself just generally warned that there would be graphic material, not specifically advising viewers they were about to watch a graphic beating. Further, the video was on auto-play so it started playing even if viewers didn’t opt to watch it. If hadn’t flagged warnings throughout the story and in other instances about the graphic nature of the video, the council indicated it would have ruled against the publication. As such, the council reminded that “great care needs to be exercised” so viewers know what they are about to see.

In an online archive of the story, the images themselves weren’t labeled graphic, but at the top of the article, posted a “Warning: Graphic Images” label.


Submit a tip / Report a problem

Graphic Video of Brazilian Transgender Woman being Beaten in Public Interest, Press Council says

Share this article:

One Response

  1. Kim Volkmar says:

    What’s going on with all the censure lately? We are adults who have lost the right to comment on articles on msn, yahoo, and so many other sites. We are being treated like children. Could it be that facebook and all the other liberal-dribble is offended by conservative comments. Ridiculous crap. At least your site took a chance and i commend you for that! Thank you!

Comments Terms and Conditions

  • We reserve the right to edit/delete comments which harass, libel, use coarse language and profanity.
  • We moderate comments especially when there is conflict or negativity among commenters.
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *